Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work

Shop Class as Soulcraft An Inquiry into the Value of Work A philosopher mechanic s wise and sometimes funny look at the challenges and pleasures of working with one s hands Called the sleeper hit of the publishing season The Boston Globe Shop Class as Soul

  • Title: Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work
  • Author: Matthew B. Crawford
  • ISBN: 9780143117469
  • Page: 446
  • Format: Paperback
  • A philosopher mechanic s wise and sometimes funny look at the challenges and pleasures of working with one s hands Called the sleeper hit of the publishing season The Boston Globe , Shop Class as Soulcraft became an instant bestseller, attracting readers with its radical and timely reappraisal of the merits of skilled manual labor On both economic and psychologi A philosopher mechanic s wise and sometimes funny look at the challenges and pleasures of working with one s hands Called the sleeper hit of the publishing season The Boston Globe , Shop Class as Soulcraft became an instant bestseller, attracting readers with its radical and timely reappraisal of the merits of skilled manual labor On both economic and psychological grounds, author Matthew B Crawford questions the educational imperative of turning everyone into a knowledge worker, based on a misguided separation of thinking from doing Using his own experience as an electrician and mechanic, Crawford presents a wonderfully articulated call for self reliance and a moving reflection on how we can live concretely in an ever abstract world.

    • ï Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work || ✓ PDF Read by ↠ Matthew B. Crawford
      446 Matthew B. Crawford
    • thumbnail Title: ï Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work || ✓ PDF Read by ↠ Matthew B. Crawford
      Posted by:Matthew B. Crawford
      Published :2019-03-26T11:26:38+00:00

    1 thought on “Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work”

    1. It was at times a bit idealistic, but the points that Crawford makes are more often than not valid and worthy of contemplation. He does seem prone to sweeping statements rather than simple conclusions, but aren't we all?The main hypothesis is that thinking and doing are inseparable from each other. And our modern life is obsessed with attempting to separate them. This causes an unnecessary psychic distancing between ourselves and our work value, which in turn affects our fulfillment.I greatly en [...]

    2. I’m always wondering why I work (aside from that whole food and shelter thing), so books that try to answer that question draw my attention. While said attention was utterly wasted on Alain de Botton’s The Pleasures and Sorrows of Work, it reaped rich rewards from Crawford’s Shop Class as Soulcraft, a thoughtful, synthetic, opinionated exploration of manual labor.Crawford argues that society undervalues working with your hands, and that physically manipulating the world demands as much int [...]

    3. With each word of this book, I want to jump up and yell, "Huzzah!" I found myself frequently laying the book down and staring out the window, contemplating how wonderful it is to work with one's hands, and more importantly, to learn from another human being, to learn things that cannot be manualized or codified. I am reminded of CS Lewis' essay "Good Work and Good Works" in which he says that the only jobs that are worth doing are the things that people would do for themselves if they didn't hav [...]

    4. I really liked the idea behind this book (or at least what I thought the idea would be from the book cover) - which defended jobs that require real, measurable work over the "information" or "knowledge" work that is so common today. My initial impression was that this could even be targeted towards the high-school student deciding what career to pursue - and after reading a number of technical books, I was looking forward to some lighter reading for a vacation.However, this book started and ende [...]

    5. Finished. It failed to redeem itself.In general terms, any book which can be summarized as "A treatise on the moral an intellectual virtues of this practice, which I happen to participate" is worthy of some skepticism, but when the subtext might further read "Justifying my life decisions" then you know you're in trouble. This book jumps into this category with both feet.I won't say there are no good ideas in here - the thesis that there is much value to be found in "real" work is one I wholehear [...]

    6. I was intrigued enough by Matthew Crawford's essay in the NYT magazine to read his entire book, which is called Shop Class as Soulcraft. Imagine an extended meditation, by someone with a Ph.D. who has extensively studied the ancient Greek philosophers, about the meaning of happiness as it relates to finding a satisfying job in the modern world. He has a snappy writing style that might remind you of Michael Kinsley or Sam Harris. There are two groups of people who might want to read the whole boo [...]

    7. What a disappointment this book was I cannot imagine that anyone who ever took a shop class in high school could possibly have enjoyed this book. It was so full of over-analytical philosophizing by a Ph.D. in Philosophy who decided to quit the "think tank" rat race of academia to run a shop doing motor cycling repair. I applaud him for knowing what he really wanted to do and then actually doing it. And even though he lists his reasons for writing the book in the next to the last chapter (somethi [...]

    8. I grew up in a working class family. Throughout my childhood, Dad always had me working at his side completing various project and side-jobs. He saw the beauty in his children being to work with their hands and believed it was the best hedge against starving to death. He had a strong work ethic and loved to tinker around his shop. He also drew great satisfaction in seeing a job come to completion and admired ingenuity over wealth. There was a certain beauty attached to something that came out of [...]

    9. I really wanted to like this book. I read an excerpt and really enjoyed it. The first half was pretty good, and had some interesting things to say about the nature of work and the value of satisfaction. But by the end of the book, the author just comes across as a giant douchebag who needs to justify to himself why he wasted years getting a PhD in philosophy when what he really wanted to do was fix motorcycles. I think he has a great point that there is a great deal of value in hands-on work (la [...]

    10. This was such a disappointment. I read a New York Times Sunday Magazine article that was a summary of this book a number of years ago when it first came out. I really liked the article and immediately added the book to my "to read" list. I only now got around to it.I hated it. HATED it. I thought Crawford was a sexist blowhard with weak arguments that contained almost no evidentiary support. In order to make said arguments appear slightly more legitimate, he dressed them up in fancy philosophica [...]

    11. I highly recommend this to anyone who's ever questioned the utility of their college or graduate degree. While I am proud and happy that I have a B.A I can't say that I think it is what will get me too far in life, and is pretty definitely not indicative of what I really enjoy in life. I've been working in carpentry/landscaping/maintenance more or less since graduating college in May 2009, and I've never felt more challenged and fulfilled than when I do a good job framing a building or siding a [...]

    12. I'd summarize this book as "Manual work is intellectually stimulating." The writing is a bit thick (the author has a PhD and writes like he has to prove it,) but the book has a thorough philosophy on the nature of manual labor and mastering one's craft.Personally, I thought it was interesting that his old job consisted of summarizing articles from academic journals. At one point, I would have described that as kind of a dream job: I would get to learn, write, and distill information from a very [...]

    13. This book is fantastic. As a former carpenter, who at the risk of sounding self-congratulatory thought myself a craftsman, I found his writing to open up a deep sense of kinship. This is a man who cares deeply about his work and his society. As someone who now works extensively with technology and computers, I found his mild technophobia a little misplaced but highly likeable. I see no difference between working with physical objects and working with bits and bytes, but that's my personal feelin [...]

    14. I don't think I disagree with much in this book, and I would unreservedly recommend it to everyone. Its themes - that a college-educated workforce is often required to check its brains, independent thinking, judgment, and problem-solving instincts at the cubicle, and that the trades or other artisanal type work actually do involve more of those traits than much white collar labor - are critically important and deserve wider discussion, especially among society's elites: policymakers, academics, [...]

    15. I was utterly taken with this book, first to last. The philosophical portions were elegantly written, insightful, and persuasive. The anecdotal interludes about car and motorcycle repair gave just enough breathing space (and entertainment) to make for a good reading pace. What a remarkable author; I will be reading anything by him I can get my hands on. On to “The World Outside Your Head.”A friend commented that he found the philosophical portions difficult, and that his father, with an MA i [...]

    16. This book appalled me, even though the premise is wonderful: a reminder to enjoy work that changes the world in a tangible way--work that uses tools and is done with your hands instead of your mind. Great! But almost every reference in the book has to do with Men Finding Meaning. About the only reference to a woman at work is a single paragraph where the omnipresent "he" in this book turns to a "she," and "she" is baking with a Betty Crocker cake mix. "She" never gets to do electrical work, or m [...]

    17. I'd probably have given this book 5 stars if Crawford didn't come across as such a macho prick (the reason I say he's a macho prick is summed up well by this NY Times book review and this one in the New Yorker). It's unfortunate that Crawford allows his tough guy persona to seep onto the page, because the book is very compelling otherwise. It does an excellent job of explaining why office work is so demeaning and unfulfilling (hint: it's often planned to be that way), despite the fact that worki [...]

    18. I've struggled w/ the star # rating for this book and am going to go with what I really think, and even then I admit I'm maybe bumping this up a bit. This is such a painfully egg-headed and cerebral book that, geez, I feel like a dunce for downgrading it, but there you go. It was just SO painfully egg-heady, cerebral, and plain I'm-so-fricking-holier-than-thou that I feel like the joy was just sucked right out of the book. Geez, Mr. Crawford, I give up! You ARE a better person than just about an [...]

    19. Was rooting for Crawford to win me over with this book so hard, but he didn't quite do it. It would be so awesome he had both the diagnosis and remedy for my vague "knowledge worker" malaise. He makes some provocative arguments, and his chapter on the contradictions of office jobs was cathartic, but at the end, I was surprised by how flimsy the central argument was for someone who studied philosophy. He tells us to choose a career that deals with things that are "real" without ever fully definin [...]

    20. A great premise marred by odd moments of sexism and condescension. Crawford has some really powerful insights into the mind-numbing culture of some corporations and makes a strong case for the intrinsic value of labor, as it creates agency, personal discipline, and true creative thinking within an individual. He argues that middle management often condescends to workers, whether it's Henry Ford's assembly line or today's cubicles, creating dysfunctional cultures. But then there are these off-kil [...]

    21. Perhaps a rather middle-class, rose-tinted view of the trades and craftsmanship - it reminded me a little of How To Be Free - “it’s great to do manual work, but to do so properly you have to have a very well read, philosophical understanding of it”. I wasn't so keen on the biography/nitty gritty of how to make motorcycles (the whole point being you have to learn by doing, not by text books, so trying to explain mechanisms wasn't that great!), so the middle 4 chapters could have been cut ou [...]

    22. I suppose one could say that this book was impactful considering I now want to quit my job and fix airplanes or something. Crawford hits the proverbial nail on the head (and then tells you you're more human for using that hammer and nail). I've always had an affinity for manual labor and the trades but was caught under the spell of the magnificent, successful "knowledge worker" vision. The book takes a very philosophical approach to the nature of work and relies on an anthropology that assumes h [...]

    23. Ken Myers (Mars Hill Audio Journal) introduced me to Matthew Crawford, calling Shop Class as Soulcraft a hymn to the virtues of what he called manual competence and a lament for the decline of honor accorded to work with one's hands.My husband, a former high school shop teacher, was captivated from the first page — bemoaning the disappearance of shop classes from our common education — kept interrupting my reading of another book to share a paragraph of this book. Thus, he convinced me to re [...]

    24. I had been looking forward to reading this for some time. I am an artist, a craftsperson who works with her hands. I form functional objects out of clay using artisan methods and traditional tools. My husband fixes machines, like motorcycles and cars and airplanes (and whatever else comes his way). I obviously share the author's value for physical work, craftsmanship and process.I never finished Zen and the Art of Motorcycle maintenance, and at times this book, too, gets too much into motorcycle [...]

    25. Surprisingly not once is Tim Allen's show within a show "Tool Time" from "Home Improvement" mentioned in this homage to the superiority of the tradesman to the knowledge worker. At a time when more schools were closing down shop programs this TV show which worshipped tinkering with tools was a big hit. But then this is a serious book with no time for comic irony. This book is at times quite thought provoking and other times the reader is left rereading a sentence or two and wondering "what did h [...]

    26. This is not just a manifesto in favor of manual labor (all sorts, not just artisanry or craftsmanship) but also against the stockade of cubicles that corporate America has encased most of us in. Crawford appears to have something large and angular lodged in his lower intestines--just peek at his multipage rant against automatic faucets in public bathrooms, which he views as a Stalinist plot. But he does ask a provocative question: Why, as America has become more educated, does it appear we have [...]

    27. This is like Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, but without sucking in the ways that book does. No mystical metaphysics, no attempt to be a novel. Just critical ideas and observations about work and philosophy. One of the best books I've read. Ever. No exaggeration. Amazing social analysis of work in this country, very philosophical in the best sense, well-written, and a solid challenge to my very personality in some critical ways to the place I find myself in life at this moment. It rea [...]

    28. By now, anyone with any exposure to Crawford’s book probably knows at least something of the man’s background. The marketing department at Penguin Books certainly won’t let us forget. Educated in political philosophy at the University of Chicago, he renounced his sinecure as the head of a Washington think-tank (as far as I can tell, it was related to the conservative American Enterprise Institute in some fashion) to retire to Norfolk, Virginia to open his own vintage motorcycle repair shop [...]

    29. It just so happened that I was reading this book as Mike Rowe, who is somehow now the flag-carrier for manual labor, testified before congress regarding “vocational education” programs in high schools. In my high school, there were students and teachers (mostly the latter) who referred to this part of the building, which had its own wing, as “the prole hallway,” and as the kind of guy who as an adult spends a lot of time on a web site called “,” I wasn’t exactly encouraged to go ov [...]

    30. Wowza.So many good quotes, stories, thoughts, concepts and ideas packed into one tiny package. A must-read for anyone who has worked "physical" labor. Here are some of my favorite quotes from the book, in no particular orderMANE ECONOMY"A humane economy would be one in which the possibility of achieving such satisfaction is not foreclosed ahead of time for most people. It would require a sense of scale. We in the West have arranged our institutions to prevent the concentration of political power [...]

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *